Skip to main content

OBDII Reader Review



I've tried four scanners with my Ferrari so far: (in order of acquisition)

1. EOBD Facile (app based) with generic ELM327 dongle. Free with optional in-app purchase.
2. Autel AP200 (app based) with proprietary dongle. ~$70 from Amazon - supports one car type.
3. Launch Pros Mini (dedicated device) with proprietary dongle. ~$700 from Amazon.
4. Autel MS906 (dedicated device) with direct connection. ~$1100 from manufacturer.

1. EOBD Facile App and Generic ELM327 Bluetooth Dongle



I really liked the EOBD at first. It can read both ECU banks and probably the TCU. I have a gated Ferrari 360 so no worries on that. It can't read the capote. The EOBD fell short there. I need to be able to see that system, especially live data. EOBD has the capability to record live data nicely and export it. No active tests. The trouble codes I've seen from my 360 are shown as "unknown" with no descriptions.

The EOBD Facile app comes recommended by Aldous Voice, a respected Mechanical Engineer specialising in Ferrari and Maserati.

2. Autel AP200 App and Proprietary Bluetooth Dongle



The AP200 is great. It's incredibly good for the price. Reads not only both banks but every system on the car including live data for the capote. It works every time. I leave the dongle in the glovebox in case of, well, you know. Live data but no recording of live data. No active tests. Trouble codes have the same descriptions as in the ODBII Code manual for the 360. Not as much detail. Just the title.

The AP200 generates nice reports from trouble codes and live data. The format looks very professional and can be quite useful if you want to share the information.

Here's part of a live data report:



One potential drawback of the AP200 is that it works for one car type only. If you have more than one car, you'll have to buy an upgrade. Not very expensive but a subscription expense. If I wanted to use the AP200 on more than one car, I'd buy two dongles. One for each car.

3. Launch X431 dedicated device with Bluetooth dongle

The Launch x431 was a disappointment. The live data was choppy and bounced all over the place. For instance, battery voltage at rest bounced between -26v and +20v. Impossible. While it did show the capote as a system, it couldn't read the codes nor show live data. My car had no trouble codes when I had this unit so I don't know if the descriptions are accurate or not. 

I give the X431 bonus points for a nice physical unit. It feels nice, has a dedicated dongle holder on the back and looks rugged. 

Perhaps I received a bad unit. The box looked like it had spent a lot of miles on the road. Returned it for a refund. Glad I bought it on Amazon.

4. Autel MS906 with Direct Connect Cable

The Autel MS906 seems to be the most professional of all of them. It was also the most expensive. The unit itself is very rugged and isn't just another off the shelf old Android tablet. The direct connect cable, instead of the bluetooth dongle, is a solid connection but with the wire, can be a little cumbersome. It also seems that refresh rates of live data may be faster using the direct connection vs. a Bluetooth dongle.

The capote shows accurate live data and trouble codes can be pulled from every system. The few trouble codes I've seen have had the proper descriptions for the 360. Three versions of TCU are supported, or claim to be. Can't verify that. Live data can be recorded and played back later easily. There's no way I could find to share those recordings. A bit of a disappointment there. Quite a few active (two way) tests, including one I needed: Reset Throttle Adaptations. 

Overall, I would rate the MS906 as the top shelf with the AP200 following close behind. A good scanner, and especially a two way scanner, is an important tool for pretty much any car made after 1996.

If you aren't sure about which unit you want to buy, and it's an expensive one, be sure to buy it from a retailer with a solid customer oriented return policy. Be sure to read the fine print before ordering.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Bosch Throttle Body (Holder) Woes

My 360 started going into limp mode a while back. It was subtle at first, with it starting to lose power after 4,000 RPM's and then less subtle when it would barely go above idle. Limp mode protects the car when some vital part has malfunctioned. I know a master Ferrari tech that is nice enough to answer questions for me about the car. He lives more than five hundred miles away and it's like telemedicine.  The codes indicated a problem in the drive-by-wire circuit, likely culprit: One or more TB's or the accelerator potentiometer (AP), which is the foot pedal sensor.  I had a good code reader that could monitor the AP voltages (2) and they appeared to be within specification. That left the TB's, one or both. After a long discussion with the tech, his answer was to replace the throttle bodies (TB). The Ferrari 360 has two TB's. One for each bank of four cylinders. To the Ferrari mentality, replacement could only be with two new TB's: "Ferrari likes replacing...
3 comments
Read more

Capote Elastic Bands Replacement

Virtually every Ferrari 360 and 430 has failing elastic bands in the capote, or soft top. The only cars that don't have these items failed right now have had them replaced in the last five years. My car is no exception and my original 20 year old elastic bands are well past the time they should be replaced. The top has a number of elastic bands that help control how it folds up and how things move. These bands are the same type of material as appears in underwear and stretch pants. As these things age, they wear out. So just like your old underwear, the elastic on the 360/430 top loses it's stretch. One of the things these elastic bands do is control a bar that shapes the headliner and roof line. This bar has to be pulled back and lie flat so the rest of the machinery that constitutes the top can fit into the tiny little space in the back of the car. When the elastic bands give out, the bar doesn't move to the right spot and the frame can impact on that bar as the top folds...
7 comments
Read more

Guide to Removal and Replacement of Heat Exchanger

Ferrari 360 Guide to Remove and Replace Heat Exchanger Lars K. Staack (aka lkstaack) 5/23/2021 Introduction 1. This is a first person account of removing and replacing the heat exchanger from a 2002 Ferrari 360 and is applicable to both the Modena and Spider models. I am a shade tree mechanic with decades of general experience, but only a month of Ferrari experience. This guide may assist a novice mechanic anticipate problems in advance, but expect to encounter issues that this guide does not address. Do not begin this procedure if that makes you uncomfortable. 2. This guide is for entertainment purposes only and is not intended to be official or definitive instructions. Performing these procedures introduces the possibility of personal injury and even death. This guide assumes that the mechanic is familiar with the proper use of personal safety equipment such as eye wear and gloves, safety equipment such as jack stands, and basic tools. I do not assume any responsibility for conse...
Post a Comment
Read more